The best custom rubber stamp for cards & gift wrap

We had a custom rubber stamp made for cards & gift wrap for the new shop. And now I’m wishing I had one made years ago just to use for my own personal gift wrap, note cards, and tags. The best custom rubber stamp for cards & gift wrap is from Casey Rubber Stamps.

Make sure you sign up for our weekly newsletter for Shop Most Lovely Things updates and follow along on Instagram @shopmostlovelythings

It’s made by Casey Rubber Stamps in NYC. It’s a shoebox of a shop on the lower east side, but I really wanted to pick it up and see for myself. John, the owner (I’m not sure where the name Casey is from) handles all the orders by email or phone. Each rubber stamp is made right on-site in the back of the shop.

As always I join my friends Cindy and Mary Ann to share our favorite finds of the week. I have been pretty focused on my shop opening on Tuesday, so today I bring you my favorite custom stamp shop along with a few other favorite shops in the East Village.

Casey Rubber Stamps is located at 322 East 11th Street in the East Village, NYC

Why Casey Rubber Stamps?

These are the best rubber stamps made with the highest quality materials. They will last which makes them perfect for sustainable packaging. They can be used on any kind of paper, fabric, or paper tape to customize your shipping boxes. The uses are endless.

Find something in the catalog or have a custom design made

I recently redesigned my logo and so the stamp I had made is a reflection of the new logo for the shop. All you need is a PDF or JPEG and they can make your design starting at $20. Here is a link to the page about custom orders, what they will need, and all the pricing. They make it pretty easy and it’s so fun to have a custom stamp. It would be a great gift too! Perfect gift for kids, new home, newlyweds, new baby, from the library of stamps, signatures. Whatever you can think of, they can make!

Ideas on how to use a custom stamp

• kraft paper, butcher paper gift wrap
• white or kraft paper note cards and envelopes
• paper bags
• mailing boxes and padded envelopes
• tags
• business cards
• paper mailing tape
• small drawstring bags

2. Other shops in the East Village we love

If you are going to make a trek to Casey Rubber Stamps in the East Village, you are going to want to check out these shops while you are there. The East Village has quite an eclectic collection of lovely one-of-a-kind shops. It would be a shame to go and not realize what was just around the corner! Here’s a list of some of our favorites make sure to follow @theshopkeepers on Instagram for more lovely shops in NYC and all over the world and check out their beautiful website right here.

John Derian

John Derian

6 East 2nd Street

East Village Hats

80 East 7th Street

Niconeco Zakkaya

263 East 10th Street

Bonnie Slotnick Cook Books

28 East 2nd Street

Cloak & Dagger

334 East 9th Street

Stranded Records

218 East 5th Street

A few Coffee Shops and Restaurants in the East Village that we love

Saltwater Coffee

345 East 12th Street

Ludlow Coffee Supply

176 Ludlow Street

Russ & Daughters Cafe

127 Orchard Street

Emmy Squared

83 First Avenue

3. One of my favorite Instagram accounts: Amanda Holland

@smallacornsamanda

Amanda has a shop and a cafe in Wellington, New Zealand, and has been an inspiration for as long as I have been following her. She’s a wonderful (and funny) storyteller and her love of flowers and color grabs my attention every single time! It was Amanda’s checkerboard chalkboard wall that inspired this one in our former home.

4. A Packable Sun Hat for around $25

I love this packable hat from the GAP and it’s currently 40% off.

5. A new pickleball paddle from J.McLaughlin

We recently started playing pickleball, so I was thrilled to receive this new paddle by Recess for J.McLaughlin in one of their signature prints.

Those are my favorite things this week. Let’s go see what Mary Ann and Cindy found.

Classic Casual Home

Cindy Hattersley Design